How Attitudinal Change Can Reduce Corruption In Nigeria’s Maritime Sector- Shittu

0
477
Prince Olayiwola Shittu, Immediate Past President, Association of Nigerian Licensed Customs Agents (ANLCA).

INTERVIEW

Prince Olayiwola Shittu, the immediate past National President of the Association of Nigerian Licensed Customs Agents(ANLCA)  and the Chairman of Skelas Group of Companies,  a freight forwarding , shipping , import and export firm, in this interview with SHOLA FADEYI , which was published in the latest edition of our marine and economy magazine , laments the endemic corruption in the Nigeria’s seaports, but says only a change of attitude by the stakeholders can reduce the cankerworm. He also spoke on the Act setting up the Nigerian Shippers’ Council, the NPPM ,the PSTT  and the Customs ,among other issues in the maritime sector: Excerpts:‑

 

The Nigerian Ports Process Manual(NPPM) , which I am the Chairman, has   done quite a lot of work for the Nigerian Shippers Council (NSC) and the country on an advisory basis , Pro Bono , giving advice to the Port Standing Task Team(PSST) , which is  the operational arm of the NPPM.

Advice

It is not a kind of assignment , anybody who is going to be a member, expects to  realize any pecuniary gain  . However , feelers  from the maritime sector have shown that  the quality advice that we have been giving  and , which have been assisting in the work of  the PSTT has led to a reduction in the level of bribery and corruption, in the Ports operations, and in the maritime sector.

The challenge that the NPPM   has  had is because  activities in the Port ,  were supposed to have  fine-tuned themselves if the agencies which are members of the NPPM    and the PSTT have been working together naturally as expected , but the problem is that they have rather been working individually on their own different platforms.

Dearth of Support

The issue again is that   the agencies of government in the maritime sector seem not to agree for the Shippers Council to be the lead and the coordinating agency of the NPPM as it is now ,and that is why they have not been giving the NPPM activities , the desired support.   They believe that the Acts , which set them up, is superior to that of the Council

The  Nigerian Customs Service(NCS)  has always believed  that, the Ports is a Customs Port , and that it is the owner and operator of the Port, by virtue of the Act establishing it.Also,  the  NPA is the landlord of the Ports , while  NIMASA by virtue of its Act is the Maritime Administrator, so are of the view that their Acts are superior to that of the Shippers’ Council and not ready to subject themselves to it.

 NSC Act

So, the reality is that , the Act , which sets up the Shippers’ Council is inadequate, it has not been able to give the Council the bite that it requires.All along, the Shipper’s Council has been struggling to see how it can survive, but it lacks that power of enforcement.

Until the power of enforcement is granted to the Council,  it would not be able to carry out its activities adequately and achieve its mandate  to enable it contribute more positively to the development of the Seaport sector..

Enforcement Power

The immediate past Executive Secretary/CEO of the Council , Hon. Emmanuel Jime  tried his best in making the Council to function as an Economic Regulator  .He had thought  because he was a former member of the House of Representatives, he  would be able to use his influence on  his colleagues in the House to have the Council’s Act amended to give it the power of enforcement, but he did not succeed , till he left. The truth is that without  the amendment   of  the Council’s Act,  it  cannot achieve much It

What the Council has been doing is to use the PSTT to arrest those stakeholders in the maritime sector who have been hell bent  at ensuring that things don’t work. Every efforts that have been made to control vehicular  traffic in all the seaports sector access roads  , even with the aid of the EFCC and the ICPC have been Akin to  scratching the problem on the surface.

Though  the Lagos State Government  is supposed to be backing the PSTT , to ensure that the PSTT  can carry out its activities unhindered, but everything is  still has it has been , motion without movement.

Corruption

We hear at times ,that some adjustments would be done to ensure that the purpose of government for the Ports are realised, but the issue is that the government itself in actual fact does not want much, because corruption is the bane of the maritime sector and until it is fully addressed, there will be no sustainable development.

Corruption reduction is not impossible, but the issue is that we as people as individuals and as stakeholders have to change our direction.If we do not collectively agree that enough is enough , corruption level will not be reduced.

Working at Cross Purpose

For instance, take the ongoing repair of the roads, particularly along the Tin Can corridor to make sure that vehicular traffic is seamless, but the issue is that the major stakeholders, which  vehicles  are operating  along that corridor, namely AMATO , NARTO have been working at cross purposes.

Again , the problem really  is that government itself is not helping matters, it is not showing adequate level of commitment, because leadership matters a lot, particularly , for  it to enforce and say this is the way things should go.

Multiple Checks

Take Customs, for instance ,after all the examinations, which they  must have carried out on goods, the freight forwarders  will still  have the goods , he has cleared from the Ports   subjected  to the notorious multiple checks at the Port.

Also, the recurring giving of targets to Customs by the Federal Government has not been helping matters and have been encouraging corruption  in the Customs, because as the government  gives revenue targets to  customs,, the officers would likewise be setting their own targets, for their pockets.

Even ,  with the current Comptroller General being on  the saddle , the individual officer would continue to use the opportunity of his uniform to tell you that, his decision on a particular matter of value interpretation, is final and that you cannot do his job for him.

Arms twisting

This is , as the other agencies at Ports, namely Quarantine, NAFDAC and the others will tell you that they have their own Acts setting them up, and when an argument ensues between them and the agents on a particular issue relating to their operations,   , all they will tell you is to go and pay , whether you agree with them or not, and the amount is always outrageous all in their bid to make the targets that have been given to them by government.

For instance, a Standard Organization of Nigeria staff will tell you that because you don’t have SONCAP, go and pay N1million into the coffers of government, but when you tell him discreetly that  you will give him some part of that money, instead of paying such an amount, he will change tune and say what is incorrect before is now correct.

Solution

So many a stakeholder are confused to what is the solution to the corruption at the Ports.It had become endemic. This is because all the personnel of the  agencies in the maritime sector, namely NPA, NIMASA  and others   are involved in the corruption acts, and it is only attitudinal change and God that can reduce corruption in the maritime sector and in  Nigeria. Without this corruption cannot go anywhere in Nigeria, we are stocked with it.

On the issue of Customs, there is no way government can be giving revenue target to    Customs and still expects it to facilitate trade. The reason for trade facilitation is  when you are able to clear your goods from the port, once you make your declarations and you are issued Pre Assessment Report (PAR) by the same Customs, but this is not so.

Pre- Arrival Assessment Report

This  is  because officers at  the ports will tell you , when you are to take delivery  of your goods ,that the value issued to you on your PAR is incorrect, and you will need to go and pay the additional value, whereas the same Customs issued the PAR, we are talking about.

The issue is that not  even Ali Hameed ,the ex Customs CG will tell you not to pay such money , which  are usually issued , through DN, in  as much as the money is going into the government coffers. All you are told at times is ,  if you discover  that you have been over charged, you can apply for refund ,but nobody has ever gotten any refund.

Trade Facilitation

Trade facilitation in customs should also mean that based on the value on your PAR , you are suppose to take delivery of your goods from the Port and come later to meet Post Audit Unit of the Customs to prove that the value is in order  , but the value can never be in order, because the officers have something in it for  themselves.

The current Customs CG is saying that he can manage to  combine trade facilitation with revenue target and is telling stakeholders not to blame customs ,because the Service must  respond to the request of government to bring money.

It is true that customs has been generating the revenue , but it has been doing so, through arm twisting.The issue  again is that Customs is always right and as   bloody  civilians, which the customs agents are,  you cannot say they are wrong.

Cargo Examination

The problem, again is that as agents, as you are arguing with the customs officers on the value in your PAR, the officials of other agencies involved in cargo examination are standing on your shoulders,  believing that there must be something to gain by the customs officers , they  will now  also begin in their own drilling when you get to their offices , all because of corruption and at the end of the day , the goods and the agents are stalled at the Ports.

Old Order In Customs

To  unbundle such a problem is really magical   because in all the years that one has been a freight forwarder, customs has always had the upper hand.One does not know if the current CG will have a magical wand to the problem , because it is the old order that is prevailing.

Imagine , every customs controller at the Command will announce ,now and then  that he has recorded an increase in revenue, but how has that been achieved, moreso, now that exchange rate is flip-flopping , and at the end of the day it is the importer who suffers, and the brunt is passed on to the consumers at the ports in terms of high  prices .